When an individual commits a crime they are held to account for their misdoings. They may receive a prison term, a fine or both. They may also get mandated counseling.
When a coach or manager of a sports team makes constant blunders, or is unable to inspire his players to perform on the field, they are fired.
But when city officials screw up, when they drop the ball, when they seem unable to fulfill their mission, to guard the quarterback’s ‘blind side,’ to execute a bunt or make the critical field goal, they rarely are held accountable.
On Tuesday The Rochester City Council will hold a public hearing regarding the Oct. 20 water-sewer user rates presentation by a hired consulting firm.
During the meeting Raftelis Consulting representatives are expected to explain the rationale for possible scenarios that would raise rates to offset the deficits that built up over the last several years in the system's enterprise account.
Earlier this fall the water/sewer enterprise account was deemed insolvent to the tune of about a $7.5 million deficit.
City officials and council members have acknowledged they were aware of the mounting deficit, but did nothing about it.
The fiscal malfeasance was blatant, irresponsible and unforgivable.
City officials basically hid their heads in the sand till an independent auditor told the city it was between a rock and a hard place regarding the account's negative balance.
For those who don’t know an enterprise account is used for things like water/sewer systems, or a town ambulance service, that takes in money from fees etc. Now in theory, those fees are supposed to pay the expenses or at least subsidize maintaining the service.
But in the case of Rochester’s water/sewer situation, operational costs and mandated upgrades due to regulation forced the city to spend beyond what was being brought in, without raising rates proportionately over many years.
So the auditor put it kind of bluntly: If you don’t pay off about $7.35 million to bring the enterprise account current, the city’s is going to see its bond rating plummet, which means anytime the city needs to borrow money the interest is going to cost more, a lot more.
Meanwhile, the city's rainy day fund - also called unassigned fund balance or 'cookie jar' - has pretty much run dry.
So the city took out a loan for $7.35 million to pay down the enterprise account deficit.
The interest rate is expected to be around 6.5 percent.
Here are some figures that show what the interest for a $7.35 million loan would be over various payment plans.
Estimated Payment Scenarios (at 6.25% Interest Rate)
10-Year Term (120 months):
Monthly Payment: $82,525.87
Total Estimated Interest: $2,553,104.54
15-Year Term (180 months):
Monthly Payment: $63,020.58
Total Estimated Interest: $3,993,704.52
20-Year Term (240 months):
Monthly Payment: $53,723.22
Total Estimated Interest: $5,543,573.49
30-Year Term (360 months):
Monthly Payment: $45,255.21
Total Estimated Interest: $8,941,877.12
The city has not released which repayment time frame they have chosen, but water and sewer users will bear the full brunt of the $7.35 million loan and all the increased costs that are associated with maintaining the water and sewer system.
We believe the residents of Rochester deserve to know how this folly occurred, not only for their satisfaction, but to ensure that something like this never ever happens again.
- HT