Man who robbed Knight Street Cumberland Farms in August gets year in jail; it was his 2nd Cumby's robbery

Nov 16, 2026 at 12:13 pm


Staff reports DOVER – The man who robbed the Rochester Cumberland Farms on Knight Street in August was sentenced on Friday to a year in county jail following a plea and sentencing hearing in Strafford Superior Court. David Matthew Shibles, 26, of Brown Street in Milton, entered the Knight Street Cumby’s around 9 a.m. on Aug. 6 telling the clerk, “I have a gun, give me all your money,” according to a Rochester Police affidavit. The clerk turned over a little more t...

Sorry - Access to this content is only for subscribers. You can purchase a Subscription in our store by clicking here.

Purchase a Subscription